By
Dr. CHARLES MALIK 1980, address at Wheaton College
"If you win the whole world and lose the mind of the world,
you will
soon discover you have not won the world.
Indeed it may turn out that
you have
actually lost the world....
Responsible Christians face two
tasks—
that of saving the soul
and that of saving the mind."
—Charles
Malik, The Two Tasks
Dr. Malik, outstanding scholar, educator and statesman, held over 50 honorary doctorates and served the University throughout his life. He was President of the United Nations General Assembly and the Secuity Council.
The following is an excerpt from Dr. Malik's speech given at the dedication of the Billy Graham center at Wheaton College:
NOTHING IS AS IMPORTANT IN THE WORLD TODAY AS for the Christians of America to
grasp their historic opportunities and prove themselves equal to them.
I say "the Christians," but I must add also "the Jews," because what is
fatefully at stake today is the highest spiritual values of the Judeo
Christian tradition. If the highest Christian values are overturned, so
will the highest Jewish values.
Perhaps never since the Twelve Disciples and Saint Paul has any group
of Christians been burdened by Providence itself with the
responsibilities now devolving upon the Christians of America.
In the nature of case, evangelization is always the most important task
to be undertaken by mortal man. For proud and rebellious and self
sufficient man--and pride and rebellion and self sufficiency are the
same thing-to be brought to his knees and to his tears before the
actual majesty and grace and power of Jesus Christ is the greatest
event that can happen to any man. Indeed just as every man is ordained
to die, so every man is ordained to this event happening in his own
life. And those who are engaged in mediating this event, the
evangelists, are the supreme heralds of God.
But just as we are not alone with God and the Bible but also with
others, so we are not only endowed with a soul and a will to be saved
but also with a reason to be sharpened and satisfied. This reason
wonders about everything, including God, and we are to seek and love
and worship the Lord our God with all our strength and all our mind.
And because we are with others, we are arguing and reasoning with one
another all the time. Indeed every sentence and every discourse is a
product of reason. And so it is neither a shame nor a sin to discipline
and cultivate our reason to the utmost; it is a necessity, it is a
duty, it is an honor to do so.
Therefore, if evangelization is the most important task, the task that
comes immediately after it--not in the tenth place, nor even the third
place, but in the second place-is not politics, nor economics, nor the
quest of comfort and security and ease, but to find out exactly what is
happening to the mind and the spirit in the schools and universities.
The Divorce between Reason and Faith
And once a Christian discovers that there is a total divorce between
mind and spirit in the schools and universities, between the perfection
of thought and the perfection of soul and character, between
intellectual sophistication and the spiritual worth of the individual
human person, between reason and faith, between the pride of knowledge
and the contrition of heart consequent upon being a mere creature, and
once he realizes that Jesus Christ will find Himself less at home on
the campuses of the great universities, in Europe and America, than
almost anywhere else, he will be profoundly disturbed, and he will
inquire what can be done to recapture the great universities for Jesus
Christ, the universities which would not have come into being in the
first place without Him.
What can the poor church, even at its best, do, what can
evangelization, even at its most inspired, do, what can the poor
family, even at its purest and noblest, do, if the children spend
between fifteen and twenty years of their life, and indeed the most
formative period of their life, in school and college in an atmosphere
of formal denial of any relevance of God and spirit and soul and faith
to the formation of their mind? The enormity of what is happening is
beyond words.
The church and the family, each already encumbered with its own strains
and ordeals, are fighting a losing battle, so far as the bearing of the
university upon the spiritual health and wholeness of youth is
concerned. All the preaching in the world, and, all the loving care of
even the best parents between whom there are no problems whatever, will
amount to little, if not to nothing, so long as what the children are
exposed to day in and day out for fifteen to twenty years in the school
and university virtually cancels out, morally and spiritually, what
they hear and see and learn at home and in the church. Therefore the
problem of the school and university is the most critical problem,
afflicting Western civilization. And here we meet laughing and relaxing
and enjoying ourselves and celebrating as though nothing of this order
of gravity were happening!
I assure you, so far as the university is concerned, I have no patience
with piety alone--I want the most rigorous intellectual training, I want
the perfection of the mind; equally, I have no patience with reason
alone--I want the salvation of the soul, I want the fear of the Lord, I
want at least neutrality with respect to the knowledge of Jesus Christ.
What I crave to see is an institution that will produce as many Nobel
Prize winners as saints, an institution in which, while producing in
every field the finest works of thought and learning in the world,
Jesus Christ will at the same time find Himself perfectly at home in
it--in every dormitory and lecture hall and library and laboratory. This
is impossible today. Why it is impossible, is the most important
question that can be asked.
The sciences are flourishing as never before, and may they keep on flourishing and exploding and discovering!
And lest I be misunderstood, let me state at once that I consider
Freiburg, the Sorbonne, Harvard, Princeton, and Chicago among the
greatest--and some of them the greatest--universities in the world, and,
provided my children qualify, I would certainly send them to them. The
diversity and quality of the intellectual fare available to the student
in these universities is absolutely unprecedented in history. Western
civilization can be proud of many things; of nothing it can be more
proud than of its great universities.
But I am worried about the humanities--about philosophy, psychology,
art, history, literature, sociology, the interpretation of man as to
his nature and his destiny. It is in these realms that the spirit, the
fundamental attitude, the whole outlook on life, even for the scientist
himself, are formed and set. Nor am I unaware and unappreciative of the
great advances achieved in the methods, techniques and tools of
education, and in the remarkable enlargement of the scope of the
curriculum. But in terms of content and substance, what is the dominant
philosophy in the humanities today?
We find on the whole and for the most part materialism and hedonism;
naturalism and rationalism; relativism and Freudianism; a great deal of
cynicism and nihilism; indifferentism and atheism; linguistic analysis
and radical obfuscation; immanentism and the absence of any sense of
mystery, any sense of' wonder, any sense of tragedy; humanism and self
sufficiency; the worship of the future, not of something above and
outside and judging past, present, and future; the relative decay of
the classics; the uncritical worship of everything new and modern and
different; a prevailing false conception of progress; an uncritical and
almost childish optimism; an uncritical and morbid pessimism; the will
to power and domination. All of which are essentially so many modes of
self worship. Any wonder there is so much disorder in the world!
If what I say is true, then as Christians you should not be able to
sleep not only tonight but for a whole week. But I know you are going
to sleep very soundly tonight, probably because you do not believe me,
probably because you do not care!
At the heart of all the problems facing Western civilization-the
general nervousness and restlessness, the dearth of grace and beatify
and quiet and peace of soul, the manifold blemishes and perversions of
personal character; problems of the family and of social relations in
general, problems of economics and politics, problems of the media,
problems affecting the school itself and the church itself, problems in
the international order--at the heart of the crisis in Western
civilization lies the state of the mind and the spirit in the
universities.
The University--Future World Leaders
It is totally vain, it is indeed childish, to tackle these problems as
though all were well, in morals and in the fundamental orientation of
the will and mind, in the great halls of learning. Where do the leaders
in these realms come from? They all come from universities. What they
are fed, intellectually, morally, spiritually, personally, in the
fifteen or twenty years they spend in the school and university, is the
decisive question. It is there that the foundations of character and
mind and outlook and conviction and attitude and spirit are laid, and,
to paraphrase a Biblical saying, if the wrong foundations are laid, or
if the right foundations are vitiated or undermined, "what can the
righteous do?" (Psalm 11:3).
The problem is not only to win souls but to save minds. If you win the
whole world and lose the mind of the world, you will soon discover you
have not won the world. Indeed it may turn out that you have actually
lost the world.
In order to create and excel intellectually, must you sacrifice or
neglect Jesus? In order to give all your life to Jesus, must you
sacrifice or neglect learning and research? Is your self giving to
scholarship and learning partially incompatible with your self giving
to Jesus? These are the ultimate questions, and I beg you to beware of
thinking that they admit of glib answers. I warn you: the right answers
could be most disturbing.
If Christians do not care for the intellectual health of their own
children and for the fate of their own civilization, a health and a
fate so inextricably bound up with the state of the mind and spirit in
the universities, who is going to care? The task is gigantic, and for
it to be accomplished as I believe Christ Himself would want it to be
accomplished, people must be set on fire for it. It is not enough to be
set on fire for evangelization alone.
Developing Creative Thinkers
This is a solemn occasion. I must be frank with you: the greatest
danger besetting American Evangelical Christianity is the danger of
anti intellectualism. The mind as to its greatest and deepest reaches
is not cared for enough. This cannot take place apart from profound
immersion for a period of years in the history of thought and the
spirit. People are in a hurry to get out of the university and start
earning money or serving the church or preaching the Gospel. They have
no idea of the infinite value of spending years of leisure in
conversing with the greatest minds and souls of the past, and thereby
ripening and sharpening and enlarging their powers of thinking.
The result is that the arena of creative thinking is abdicated and
vacated to the enemy. Who among the Evangelicals can stand up to the
great secular or naturalistic or atheistic scholars on their own terms
of scholarship and research? Who among the Evangelical scholars is
quoted as a normative source by the greatest secular authorities on
history or philosophy or psychology or sociology or politics? Does your
mode of thinking have the slightest chance of becoming the dominant
mode of thinking in the great universities of Europe and America which
stamp your entire civilization with their own spirit and ideas?
It will take a different spirit altogether to overcome this great
danger of anti intellectualism. As an example only, I say this
different spirit, so far as the domain of philosophy alone is
concerned, which is the most important domain so far as thought and
intellect are concerned, must see the tremendous value of spending a
whole year doing nothing except poring intensely over the Republic or
the Sophist of Plato, or two years over the Metaphysics or the Ethics
of Aristotle, or three years over the City of God of Augustine. For the
sake of greater effectiveness in witnessing to Jesus Christ Himself, as
well as for their own sakes, the Evangelicals cannot afford to keep on
living on the periphery of responsible intellectual existence.
Save the University--Save the World
Responsible Christians face two tasks--that of saving the soul and that
of saving the mind. I am using soul and mind here without definition,
but I can define them in precise, philosophical theological terms. The
mind is desperately disordered today. I am pleading that a tiny
fraction of Christian care be extended to the mind too.
If it is the will of the Holy Ghost that we attend to the soul,
certainly it is not His will that we neglect the mind. No civilization
can endure with its mind being as confused and disordered as ours is
today. All our ills stem proximately from the false philosophies that
have been let loose in the world and that are now being taught in the
universities, and ultimately of course, as President Armerding observes
in his book Leadership in another context, from the devil, whether or
not the human agents knew it. Save the university and you save Western
civilization and therewith the world.
These two things are absolutely impossible, and because they are at the
same time absolutely needed, God can make them absolutely possible.
Every self defeating attitude stems originally from the devil, because
he is the adversary, the arch nihilist par excellence--it cannot be
willed by the Holy Ghost. Anti intellectualism is an absolutely self
defeating attitude.
Wake up, my friends, wake up: the great universities control the mind
of the world. Therefore how can evangelism consider its task
accomplished if it leaves the university unevangelized. And how can
evangelism evangelize the university if it cannot speak to the
university? And how can it speak to the university if it is not itself
already intellectualized? Therefore evangelism must first
intellectualize itself to be able to speak to the university and
therefore to be able to evangelize the university and therefore to save
the world. This is the great task, the historic task, the most needed
task, the task required loud and clear by the Holy Ghost Himself.
And if this should happen, then think of the infinite joy that would
overflow our hearts. Future generations will bless your name and sing
your praises for centuries to come. Who, then, would not join with
David in singing: "Bless the Lord, O my soul: and all that is within
me, bless his holy name. Bless the Lord, O my soul, and forget not all
his benefits. . . . I will sing unto the Lord as long as I live: I will
sing praise to my God while I have my being." (Psalm 103:1-2; and
104:33).
A Brief Introduction to Charles Malik:
Few people can match Dr. Charles Malik's credentials to critique
"the mind and spirit of the university." He was an outstanding scholar
with a Ph.D. in philosophy from Harvard, under Alfred North Whitehead,
and over fifty honorary doctorates from such universities as Yale,
Princeton, Columbia, Notre Dame, and Freiburg. Throughout his career he
published articles and books on philosophical, diplomatic, and
international matters in America, Europe, and the Middle East. Dr.
Malik also served universities throughout his life. In his own country,
he was a founding member of the Lebanese Academy. He was chairman of
the philosophy department at the American University, Beirut, then Dean
of Graduate Studies; from 1962 to 1976 he was Distinguished Professor
of Philosophy.
The authority with which Dr. Malik declaims against the university
comes also from a larger sphere, that of an international diplomat. He
was a signatory for Lebanon of the United Nations Charter in 1945. He
served the U.N. for fourteen years, at various times as President of
the General Assembly and of the Security Council. More than twelve
countries decorated him for his contributions to human rights and
international peace.
The Two Tasks speech was given by Dr. Malik at the dedication of the
Billy Graham Center in the fall of 1980, the same year Christian
Leadership Ministries was founded. Dr. Clint Shaffer, professor of
German at Wheaton College, was there: "Sharing the platform with Dr.
Graham and President Hudson Amerding was the keynote speaker, Charles
Malik, a Lebanese educator and statesman whose words profoundly changed
my attitudes toward learning and the gospel. Malik's central argument
was that Christians in general and North American evangelicals in
particular stood little chance of having a deep impact upon their
society unless they proved able to know and influence the intellectual
life of the world. We are, he contended, admonished to save both the
soul and the mind" (Wheaton Magazine, 13:4 Summer 2000).
Christianity Today first published the Two Tasks speech on November 7,
1980. The Two Tasks is available in booklet form from the Billy Graham
Center, Wheaton College, Wheaton, IL 60187. at http://bgc.gospelcom.net/emis/books.htm
|